Kushner says Russia is open to NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine
Jared Kushner said Russia was open to Article 5-style security guarantees for Ukraine, while Trump could consider the model within a broader package.
By Ahmet Taş | Wise News Press
BERLIN, GERMANY — U.S. presidential envoy Jared Kushner said Russia had become receptive to security guarantees for Ukraine modelled on NATO’s Article 5, although Moscow has not independently confirmed such an agreement.
The statement followed a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin focused on preventing another Russian attack after a potential peace settlement. The structure, enforcement mechanism and participating countries remain unresolved.
Kushner outlines possible security framework
U.S. presidential envoy Jared Kushner discussed the proposed security model after the Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin on November 19, 2026.
Kushner said the United States had succeeded in making Russian officials more comfortable with the concept of providing Ukraine with guarantees based on the principles of NATO’s collective defence clause.
His remarks did not indicate that Russia had signed or formally accepted a detailed agreement. Kushner instead suggested that Moscow was prepared to consider the concept as a possible basis for further negotiations.
According to the U.S. envoy, Russian officials have said they do not want another war to begin after the current conflict ends. Kushner acknowledged, however, that there was considerable scepticism over Moscow’s intentions.
The comments point to a possible area for negotiation, but they do not establish that the parties have agreed on how the guarantees would operate, who would provide them or what would happen if they were violated.
Trump reportedly open to Article 5-style guarantees
Kushner said U.S. President Donald Trump was open to considering a security guarantee for Ukraine resembling NATO’s Article 5.
He stressed that such a commitment would represent a major decision for the United States. Any arrangement would have to serve American interests and form part of a broader security package.
Washington does not appear to be seeking a political declaration without enforcement provisions. Kushner said the parties would need mechanisms for monitoring compliance, creating deterrence and imposing consequences in the event of a violation.
Under the developing U.S. approach, Ukraine’s security, Europe’s defence arrangements and future relations with Russia would be considered within the same broader package.
Kushner also said the Trump administration did not intend to impose a unilateral settlement on Ukraine or Europe. He maintained that any agreement would be developed through close consultations with Kyiv and European governments.
The details of the possible U.S. commitment remain unclear. Washington has not announced which actions it would take if Russia launched another attack after a peace agreement.
What NATO’s Article 5 provides
Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty is the foundation of NATO’s collective defence principle. It states that an armed attack against one member is considered an attack against all members.
Each NATO ally is required to assist the country under attack by taking the action it considers necessary. That assistance may include military force, but Article 5 does not automatically require every member to respond in exactly the same manner.
Ukraine is not currently a NATO member and is therefore not directly protected by the alliance’s collective defence clause. The model under discussion would create a separate arrangement inspired by Article 5 without necessarily granting Ukraine full NATO membership.
It remains unknown which countries would provide the guarantees, how rapidly they would respond to a new attack or whether assistance would include direct military involvement.
Kushner did not describe the legal structure, duration or enforcement mechanism of the proposed arrangement. The reference to Article 5 therefore describes a negotiating principle rather than a completed security treaty.
The guarantees would have to be sufficiently credible to deter a future attack while also gaining support from the United States, European governments and Ukraine.
No independent confirmation from Moscow
Although Kushner said Russia had become comfortable with the security concept, the Kremlin has not publicly confirmed a formal agreement accepting Article 5-style guarantees for Ukraine.
Russia has repeatedly opposed Ukraine joining NATO and has rejected the potential deployment of Western troops on Ukrainian territory. Moscow argues that such arrangements would create a security threat near its borders.
It therefore remains uncertain under which conditions Russia could accept a security framework inspired by NATO’s collective defence clause.
Moscow may distinguish between full NATO membership and a separate guarantee established outside the alliance. However, Russian officials have not publicly presented the conditions under which such a model might be acceptable.
Kushner acknowledged that there was scepticism and disbelief in Russia concerning the proposal. He said renewed dialogue between Europe and Russia was important so the parties could hear each other’s positions directly.
Until Moscow releases a detailed response, Kushner’s remarks represent the U.S. assessment of discussions with Russian officials rather than an independently verified Russian commitment.
NATO membership returns to negotiations
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy previously said the United States had raised a new question involving Ukraine’s possible NATO membership.
According to Zelenskyy, Washington asked whether Ukraine would consider withdrawing from the part of the Donetsk region it still controls in exchange for membership in the alliance.
The proposal has not been announced as an accepted or formal plan. Zelenskyy presented it as an option raised during discussions rather than an agreement approved by Ukraine, NATO or the United States.
Kyiv says it will not recognise occupied Ukrainian territories as part of Russia and will not sign a settlement without reliable security guarantees.
Zelenskyy also said Ukraine and the United States had discussed protections modelled on Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty.
Article 4 allows NATO members to request consultations when they believe their territorial integrity, political independence or security is threatened. Article 5 establishes the principle of collective assistance following an armed attack.
Combining elements of both provisions could provide consultations before a crisis and a predetermined response if Ukraine were attacked again.
U.S. troops not included in current proposal
According to Zelenskyy, the security guarantee currently being discussed does not include the deployment of American troops in Ukraine.
That detail could be significant because Moscow has strongly opposed the presence of Western forces on Ukrainian territory.
The parties could instead consider weapons supplies, intelligence cooperation, air defence support, military training and other deterrence measures. Such arrangements might strengthen Ukraine without creating a permanent U.S. troop presence.
However, it remains unclear how an Article 5-style guarantee could be enforced without military personnel in Ukraine and which countries would respond in the event of another attack.
Kyiv is seeking more than political assurances. Ukrainian officials want clearly defined commitments, monitoring arrangements and predetermined consequences for any violation.
The responsibilities of each country providing a guarantee would therefore have to be described in detail before the arrangement could be considered credible.
Kyiv seeks a comprehensive security package
Zelenskyy said Ukraine was discussing a comprehensive package with its partners rather than relying on a single security clause.
Kyiv’s proposed framework includes specific guarantees from NATO and European Union countries, a strong Ukrainian military, sufficient personnel, long-term weapons supplies and sustained financial assistance.
A postwar reconstruction plan would form another central part of the package. Ukraine argues that economic recovery and the rebuilding of critical infrastructure cannot be separated from the country’s long-term security.
The plan is expected to keep the Ukrainian armed forces strong after the war. European countries could assume responsibilities in military training, defence production, air defence and long-term financing.
Important unresolved questions include the legal status of the guarantees, compliance monitoring, penalties for violations and the role of the United States.
Kushner’s statement suggests that a new negotiating possibility may have emerged. It does not, however, mean that Russia, Ukraine, the United States and Europe have reached a final agreement.
Establishing a workable Article 5-style arrangement would require further negotiations over who provides the guarantee, what actions it requires and how it would be enforced following another attack.
WiseNewsPress.com
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)